Stillwater Homes for Sale, St. Simons Island, Georgia

This remarkable lakefront lot spans just under one acre (0.90) and offers breathtaking views of the lake. Located in the well-established, gated community of Stillwater. This beautiful lot has a tree survey as well. The subdivision features a 13-acre stocked fishing lake, a park, and tennis courts. It is situated just north of Frederica Park, Sea Island Stables, and Frederica Golf Club. Adjacent to Stillwater lies 39 acres of Stillwater Reserve, a protected area ensuring no future development, allowing you to fully enjoy the wildlife and tranquility that make St. Simons so special.

149 Stillwater Drive, St. Simons

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty. Selling Office: .

$1,150,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 10411001 MLS

Presenting 28 Dorsey Circle, a pristine, custom-built home in the highly sought-after Stillwater Subdivision. This nearly-new, two-year-old residence offers effortless living in a tranquil setting nested among other attractive residences. Boasting a spacious .88-acre lot, there's potential to add a pool, outdoor pavilion, or numerous custom additions to further enhance coastal living. Inside, you'll find elegant White Oak floors, soaring 12' ceilings, and a beautifully crafted kitchen with quartzite countertops, luxurious fixtures, and an open layout ideal for entertaining. The convenient prep pantry includes a sink, extra fridge space, and an additional dishwasher, ensuring your kitchen maintains a spotless appearance. The primary suite is generously sized with a well-appointed bathroom and a closet offering space for customization and the addition of a wardrobe island. A versatile 4th bedroom, designed as a study/office or smaller guest room, adds flexibility. Relax on the fabulous rear porch with a tongue & groove wood ceiling, an inviting space for morning coffee or evening cocktails with family and friends. This home is a perfect blend of style, function, and serenity!

28 Dorsey Circle, St. Simons

Listing courtesy of BHHS Hodnett Cooper Real Estate. Selling Office: .

$2,150,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 10398166 MLS

Nestled in the highly sought-after gated subdivision of Stillwater, this custom-designed Mediterranean-style masterpiece offers an exquisite blend of elegance with a contemporary flair. Situated on nearly an acre of lush grounds overlooking the lake, this home is a true work of art, featuring top-of-the-line finishes such as reclaimed wood floors from an 1810 cotton gin factory and kiln-flashed roof tiles imported from South America. Step through the hand-carved mahogany door from Indonesia into a grand foyer, where panoramic lake views instantly captivate. These stunning vistas can be enjoyed from nearly every room. The home's design with soaring 12-foot ceilings creates a perfect flow for both intimate gatherings and large scale entertaining inside and out, where multiple covered and open verandas overlook the serene saltwater pool. Due to the thoughtful positioning on this premier lot, the home provides unparalleled privacy. The master suite spans the entire right side of the house, boasting his-and-hers walk-in closets, a luxurious bath, and a secluded veranda. The home also includes an elegant formal dining room, four spacious bedroom suites, a chef's gourmet kitchen with butler's pantry, a study, a beautifully appointed living room and den, and a large laundry room featuring a jetted laundry sink for washing delicates or even the family pets. Internet is provided by LiveOak Fiber with Wi-Fi 7 covering the entire house, perfect for enabling wireless entertainment systems, and all of the smart home features you could want. Located in a community with amenities such as private tennis courts, this captivating property is one you'll want to call home! Fly-thru drone virtual tour: https://bit.ly/139StillwaterVideo (copy & paste). BIG Buyer Incentive - Seller is offering $25,000 toward a rate buydown on this home. Here's what this could mean for YOU! For example, on a 30YR 80% Jumbo loan with a rate of 7.125%, Monthly savings: $608; Yearly savings: $7,300; Life of the loan savings: $218,000+. Lower payments, more affordability, and greater buying power putting REAL money back in your pocket - every month.

139 Stillwater Drive, St. Simons

Listing courtesy of Gardner Keim Coastal Realty. Selling Office: .

$1,700,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 10296932 MLS

Welcome to 169 Stillwater on St. Simons Island. Get ready to fall in love with this 2023 pristine lakefront home on almost an acre in a peaceful, gated neighborhood with a wealth of upscale amenities designed to elevate your lifestyle. Maximizing lake views, the four bedroom three and a half bath home with elegant touches throughout is the epitome of comfort and style. The beautiful front lawn and sophisticated architectural design are show-stopping. Step inside to a refined open plan with spectacular lake views overlooking a natural island for serene privacy. The elegant, cohesive design is expressed in ideal floorpan, beautiful materials, and exquisite fixtures. The graceful two-story living room with fireplace and expansive windows for natural light is banked by sophisticated staircase and convenient office behind double pocket doors at one end and opening to a screened porch sweeping lake vistas. Be wowed by the statement light fixture in dining area adjacent to the lake-front windowed sitting room. The chef's kitchen with 6 burner gas stove and large island with prep sink, ample storage, and seating. Overhead find designer lighting above quartz countertops and fine cabinetry. Enjoy the decadent walk-in pantry with coffee station offering a seamless blend of convenience, refinement, and lake views. Maximize time in nature in the outdoor kitchen with marine grade grill. Beauty and function unite in large mudroom with cabinetry and additional closet space. The sumptuous main level primary suite is your own personal oasis with fireplace, lake views, and luxury spa bath with double vanities, soaking tub, and shower room. Expansive closet room connects to the private laundry room with beautiful jewel-toned cabinetry. Upstairs, discover a sanctuary of relaxation and versatility, with 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, an additional laundry room, a spacious walk-in attic, and flexible living space that cater to your every desire. Highly aesthetic home is supported by top grade functionality with whole house Generac gas generator, 2 Bosch gas tankless water heaters, 2 HVAC systems, spray foam insulation, high-end appliances and fixtures, and luxury LVP flooring throughout. If you are looking for a new, stylish, luxury waterfront property with all the extra details in a gated St. Simons Island neighborhood with amenities including community tennis courts, schedule your showing today. Incomparable value!

169 Stillwater Drive, St. Simons

Listing courtesy of BHHS Hodnett Cooper Real Estate. Selling Office: .

Start Your Search

All homes in Stillwater subdivision

Stillwater Homes for Sale, St. Simons Island, Georgia

Stillwater subdivision offers homebuyers a premier island community on St. Simons Island, Georgia, located in Glynn County in zip code 31522.

Reached via the scenic F.J. Torras Causeway from Brunswick, St. Simons Island is celebrated for East Beach, the Pier Village, St. Simons Lighthouse, Sea Island and Sea Palms championship golf, moss-draped live oaks, and gated marshfront and golf course communities.

What's Great About Living in Stillwater

East Beach & Coast Guard Station

Enjoy sun-drenched days along East Beach, the Historic Coast Guard Station, Massengale Park, and miles of hard-packed sand ideal for biking and beachcombing.

Pier Village & Redfern Dining

Minutes from Mallery Street in Pier Village, the St. Simons Lighthouse, Neptune Park, Redfern Village, and acclaimed Golden Isles coastal restaurants and boutiques.

Championship Golf & Resort Lifestyle

Surrounded by premier golf destinations including the King and Prince Golf Course, Sea Palms Resort, Sea Island Golf Club, and Frederica Golf Club.

Frederica River & Marina Access

Boating, offshore fishing, and kayaking from Golden Isles Marina, MorningStar Marina at Golden Isles, Hampton River Marina, and Gascoigne Bluff.

Causeway Access to Brunswick & I-95

Direct F.J. Torras Causeway access connects island residents to Brunswick, Southeast Georgia Health System, McKinnon St. Simons Island Airport, and I-95 between Savannah and Jacksonville.

Island Trails, History & Coastal Charm

Over 30 miles of paved island bike paths linking Fort Frederica National Monument, Christ Church, Cannon’s Point Preserve, and top-rated Glynn County schools.

Buying & Selling in Stillwater: St. Simons Island, GA Real Estate Guide

VA, FHA & Conventional Home Loans

Homebuyers in Stillwater frequently utilize zero-down VA home loans (ideal for active-duty military and veterans near Naval Submarine Base Kings Bay, FLETC, and Hunter Army Airfield), low-down-payment FHA financing, and conventional loan programs. Getting pre-qualified early strengthens your negotiating position when desirable St. Simons Island listings hit the market.

Glynn County Property Taxes & Homestead Exemptions

Primary residence buyers in Stillwater can apply for the Glynn County homestead exemption to reduce annual assessed property taxes. When comparing homes in St. Simons Island, we help you review Glynn County tax histories, millage rates, and estimated monthly escrow payments alongside principal and interest.

Due Diligence, Inspections & Home Buyer FAQs

Purchasing a home in Coastal Georgia involves reviewing neighborhood HOA covenants (if applicable), checking flood zone maps, and scheduling a thorough home inspection during your due diligence period. For answers to common buyer FAQs and step-by-step guidance from lender pre-qualification to closing, read our guide on How to Buy a Home in Georgia.

Stillwater Market Comps & Resale Value

Evaluating both active MLS listings and recently sold homes in Stillwater gives buyers data-backed insight into price-per-square-foot trends, days on market, and neighborhood value—and helps Stillwater homeowners price strategically when selling. View the live St. Simons Island Market Report for current active and sold data, or create a custom market report for any neighborhood.

St. Simons Island Micro-Markets, Zip Codes & Coastal Lifestyle

Living in Stillwater places you in the heart of St. Simons Island and Glynn County—combining neighborhood comfort with convenient access to local shopping, dining, schools, and outdoor recreation. With quick access across the causeway to U.S. Highway 17, I-95, Brunswick Golden Isles Airport (BQK), and Southeast Georgia Health System, residents enjoy island living with easy connectivity to Savannah and Jacksonville.

Explore St. Simons Island Homes by Zip Code & Nearby Communities: All St. Simons Island Subdivisions (St. Simons Island Subdivisions Directory) • St. Simons Island ZIP Code (31522) • City of St. Simons Island Listings (St. Simons Island Homes) • Glynn County Listings (Glynn County Real Estate) • Brunswick (Brunswick Subdivisions) • Kingsland (Kingsland Subdivisions) • Richmond Hill (Richmond Hill Subdivisions) • Savannah (Savannah Subdivisions).

Get Pre-Qualified for a Home Loan

Explore St. Simons Island Real Estate

🗺️Interactive Map Search

Explore our map of homes for sale & pinpoint exact locations in coastal Georgia.

View Map →

🔍Advanced Search

Refine your search by price, subdivision, square footage, or specific home features.

Start Searching →

📈Real Estate Market Report

Stay informed on trends, active listings, recent sales, and average prices.

View Report →

🏘️Instant Home Valuation

Thinking of selling? Get an accurate estimate of your property's current value.

Get Valuation →

Whether you are comparing St. Simons Island subdivisions across Glynn County, evaluating recent neighborhood sales comps, or preparing a competitive offer on a home in Stillwater, our local coastal Georgia real estate team is here to guide you through every step—for answers to common buyer FAQs and step-by-step guidance from lender pre-qualification to closing, read our guide on How to Buy a Home in Georgia.

Contact us today to schedule a private tour of Stillwater homes for sale or to sell your home in Stillwater, St. Simons Island, Georgia!