Montego Bay Real Estate

Montego Bay Real Estate

Welcome to Montego Bay, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Milledgeville, Georgia. This charming subdivision offers a unique blend of serene lakeside living and vibrant community spirit, making it an ideal choice for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a peaceful retreat.

Montego Bay is characterized by its picturesque landscapes, where lush greenery meets the shimmering waters of Lake Sinclair. Residents enjoy a variety of outdoor activities, from fishing and boating to hiking along scenic trails. The community is designed for those who appreciate nature’s beauty, with well-maintained parks and recreational areas that invite leisurely strolls and family picnics.

The homes in Montego Bay are as inviting as the surroundings, featuring a mix of modern designs and classic Southern charm. Many properties boast spacious yards, perfect for gardening or hosting summer barbecues, while some offer stunning lake views that create a tranquil ambiance. The friendly atmosphere of the neighborhood fosters a sense of belonging, making it easy to meet neighbors and build lasting friendships.

Conveniently located, Montego Bay is just a short drive from the vibrant downtown Milledgeville, where you can explore local shops, restaurants, and cultural attractions. The area is rich in history, providing opportunities to enjoy museums and historic sites that tell the story of this charming Southern city.

Whether you’re looking for a weekend getaway or a permanent residence, Montego Bay offers an idyllic lifestyle that combines the best of nature and community. Come discover your dream home in this enchanting subdivision, where every day feels like a vacation!

Newest Listings in Montego Bay

$449,000
10808471 MLS
Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a build-ready, deeded waterfront lot on Lake Sinclair in a desirable, site-built-only neighborhood! Conveniently located and offering scenic water views, this property provides the perfect setting for privacy and relaxation in peaceful surroundings. The property includes a studio guesthouse that is currently generating $1,100 per month in rental income, or it can be used as a private getaway or vacation rental. Additional improvements include a private max dock and seawall. The homesite has already been cleared and is ready for construction. Power, water, and a septic system are already installed-just bring your building plans! Georgia Power has conditionally approved a single-stall boathouse, adding even more future potential. An existing driveway leads to a custom-built carport and an adorable storage shed with electricity. Whether you're ready to build your dream lake home, create the perfect weekend getaway, or invest in a property with immediate income potential, this fee-simple lot offers a tremendous head start with many major improvements already in place. Enjoy lake living from day one while planning your custom home in a community designed for lasting value and peaceful lakeside living.

136 Old Plantation Trail NW, Milledgeville

Listing courtesy of Elisabeth Barrett Realty.

$375,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 10805357 MLS
Welcome home to the Montego Bay neighborhood at Lake Sinclair. This waterfront home sits beautifully on a one-acre lot. Since ownership, Sellers have replaced the AC, installed a metal roof, new bath vanities, fireplace with gas logs, new kitchen cabinetry/counters/backsplash, water heater, refrigerator, and dock decking. The lovely private front yard is fenced-in from the house to the water and includes a great dock for fishing and relaxing with an adjacent permanent fire pit. Two outbuildings (one with electrical) accompany the property between the house and the road, and can be used for workshops, storage, etc. The home features 3 beds and 2 full baths. The main living area features a gas logs fireplace and separates the two secondary bedrooms and full bath from the oversized master bedroom which features an ensuite full bath with soaker tub. Light-filled kitchen and dining. The home also features mudroom/laundry and a large beautiful covered front porch facing the water. There is electrical at the dock which features a pump connected to a spigot for easy watering using water from the lake. Montego Bay is a peaceful, walkable neighborhood community and is very convenient to Milledgeville and Eatonton.

156 Montego Bay Road NW, Milledgeville

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty.

$798,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 10696540 MLS
Experience lakefront living at its finest in this beautifully renovated retreat perfectly positioned on one of the most breathtaking points on Lake Sinclair. Set on a gently crowned lot with approximately 660 feet of shoreline, this exceptional property offers panoramic water views in nearly every direction. Designed for both relaxation and entertaining, the home features a bright, open-concept living area where gathering comes naturally. Recent renovations blend modern comfort with timeless lakehouse charm, complemented by three bedrooms and three full bathrooms, making it ideal for hosting family and friends year-round. Outdoor living truly shines here. Enjoy sunrise coffee or sunset evenings from one of the three covered porches, each offering its own stunning vantage point of the water. This property is fully equipped for lake life, featuring a covered boathouse with two slips (including a boat lift), two docks, a utility shed for lake toys and equipment, and endless opportunities for swimming, boating, and fishing right from your backyard. Whether you're searching for a peaceful weekend escape, a full-time waterfront residence, or the ultimate place to entertain, this Lake Sinclair property delivers unmatched views, exceptional lake frontage, and unforgettable moments on the water.

166 Montego Bay Road NW, Milledgeville

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Curry Residential.

Start Your Search

© 2026 Georgia MLS. All rights reserved. Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed.